This cheese toastie is a delicious and melty sandwich that’s perfect for a midday snack, lunch, or late night noshing! The filling in these toasties is ham, Cheddar and onion, inspired by a pub lunch in Limerick, Ireland.
This post may contain affiliate links.
After a day visiting Dingle we had dinner in Castlemaine (Caisleán na Mainge) and the next day set out to visit the city of Limerick (Luimneach). My recipe in this post is for Ham, Cheese & Onion Toasties!
Jump to:
Dinner and whiskey in Castlemaine
When we returned from the Slea Head drive in Dingle to our room at Murphy’s Farmhouse, it was time to grab dinner. Fortunately for us there were two restaurants within walking distance, and we decided to go to The Anvil Bar & Restaurant right down the lane.
This area was a fairly quiet and rural one, and the folks eating and drinking at The Anvil seemed to be mostly locals. Inside we found a booth by the front window where we could settle in and enjoy the friendly atmosphere.
Instead of having a pint my sister and I decided to try some Irish whiskey. There was a helpful guide in the menu to point us towards the best whiskey for us (because I know little about whiskey… except that I like it.)
We decided to try a local single malt, from the Dingle Whiskey Distillery.
On its own it was smooth and very clean tasting. With a little ginger ale, it was quite pleasant indeed – a nice way to unwind from the day.
We enjoyed it so much that we debated stealing the glasses etched with the Dingle Distillery logo, and then let our morals get the better of us, deciding just to ask to buy some. But our waitress told us that our two Dingle glasses were the only ones the bar owned!
We began with grilled goat’s cheese crostini and the star of that appetizer was the zingy red onion marmalade that came with it! Mom tried hake for the first time, a locally-caught whitefish that John, our driver in Inishmore had told us was in season at that time of the year. It came battered like a traditional fish ‘n chips platter, and she really liked it.
My sister and I had the “Truly Irish Roast of the Day” which our waitress warned us would be the size of a big Christmas dinner. And she was right: thickly carved slices of roast turkey and ham alongside steamed veggies, mashed potatoes, and a lake of dark, rich gravy.
We feasted on the massive entrees while watching on the bar television snippets of the Rose of Tralee Pageant. Young women from Ireland and abroad (12 from the U.S.) compete to be the next Rose of Tralee, judged not on beauty but on personality, ambitions, and social responsibility.
On our last morning at the lovely Murphy’s Farmhouse I decided to skip the enormous Irish breakfast and instead had Cheddar on toast, which is just as simple as it sounds yet was so rich, gooey, and delicious!
We talked with the owner Mary about our Irish heritage and family names (Riley, Reilly, Fennessey, Lavin, Haren), and then of our plans to head to Limerick for the day. She told us that as a child she knew a family from Limerick with the surname Lavin!
Off to Limerick
We had two goals for our day in Limerick: to buy hurleys (the sticks used in the game of hurling) for our sons, and for my sister to get a tattoo. She had achieved everything on her Ireland bucket list (try Irish whiskey, have a pint in a pub, get a selfie with a sheep) and the tattoo was all that remained.
She’d been keeping her eye out for a tattoo place as we traveled, but we hadn’t come across any. (I’m sure there were plenty in Dublin but not in the tiny area we explored!) When she checked online in Limerick, she found one: Chapel Street Custom Tattoos.
In contrast to the area of Dublin that we had explored, Limerick felt very urban. The majority of the people we saw were residents – heading to work, taking lunch, pushing babies in strollers.
As we walked we saw lots of bakeries and cafés, and several butcher’s shops with beautifully lavish displays of meats and fish, and the butchers all in striped aprons and bowler hats. One of these butchers gave us directions to a local tea shop where we bought some Irish teas to take back home.
We also figured Limerick would be a perfect place to pick up the hurleys, as they had just won the All Ireland Championship that week, their first championship win in 45 years.
There were still green and white flags hanging in shops and strung across the streets in celebration of the All Ireland win, and we heard from a few shop owners that it had been quite the party when the team came home with the trophy.
We found our hurleys and sliotars in a local sporting goods shop, and the young man who helped us looked just like Colin Hanks!
What the heck is hurling?
Hurling is the national sport of Ireland and variations have been played there for thousands of years. The matches are played on a field longer than a football field, and the players run and collide the length of it endlessly while trying to score.
The sticks (hurleys) are similar to field hockey sticks but with a flared end tapered like a blade. With that stick you can hit the sliotar (a small ball) on the ground or in the air. You can bounce the sliotar on the end of that stick – while running! You can hit it with your hand. You can hit other players with that stick… or with your fist! (Well, at least in the video I watched they did.) It is really wild.
While watching the videos I wondered if hurling had been, in part at least the inspiration for the game of Quidditch in the world of Harry Potter. The sliotar in hurling is about the size of the Golden Snitch, and like Quidditch the sport has its brutal moments!
Cheese toasties for lunch
My sister found the Chapel Street shop and made plans with the owner to return in a short time for her tattoo. Right across the street was Charlie Chaplin’s Pub and we headed in to find some lunch. As it was pretty early in the day and the bar had just opened, the only food they had to offer us were toasties.
This was not the first time we had seen toasties on menus during the week. When I had asked at one restaurant if a toastie was just a grilled cheese sandwich, a waitress told me that it was but that you “could put anything inside it.”
At Charlie Chaplin’s Pub the toasties were ham, onion, and cheese and served with Tayto Cheese & Onion chips (which mom fell in love with! Seriously, she ordered a case of them once we got back home!)
The toastie was pressed in a panini press (but with flat plates, so there were no ridges on our sandwiches.) The cheese was melty, the bread toasty and buttery, and the whole thing really hit the spot!
After my sister went in to get inked, my mom and I did some more wandering. We stopped in a café for tea and Americano, brown bread with butter and a decadent tiffin which is a sweet bar of digestive biscuits (like Graham crackers) crushed and suspended in chocolate. We found a yarn shop for mom to explore, and a second-hand store where I bought a 45 of the song “Only You” by Yazoo.
And a short time after we left her, my sister was done! Her tattoo has her sons’ names (my nephews) written in ancient Ogham (lines and crosshatches), the first language of Ireland.
With that our Limerick day was done, and we were off to our final B&B of the trip – the Dunaree B&B in Bunratty.
Toasties, and why you’ll love them
Once home and doing more research on toasties, I found this funny and very helpful article from The Guardian.com on what a toastie is and what it is not. In short, a toastie is meant to be simple and humble, a mid-afternoon or late-night snack, a lazy Saturday lunch, or (quite popularly) a post-hangover meal.
It’s made of basic white bread buttered on the outside, and with fillings that are not gourmet and that won’t squish or leak out. The sandwich is compressed and grilled to fuse everything together.
Which is why the ham, cheese, and onion toastie we had in Limerick was so perfect – a grilled cheese but also better than just a grilled cheese.
🔪 How to make a toastie
Step 1: Assemble the sandwiches
Butter the slices of white bread on one side, then flip them over to spread the other sides with mustard. Add in slices of Cheddar, thinly sliced ham, and diced, sautéed onion. (You can add in beans too if you’d like!) Put the sandwiches together with the buttered sides facing out.
Step 2: Toast them
Heat up a skillet and place the sandwiches in the hot pan. Compress the sandwiches in the pan with a small cutting board or plate topped with something heavy, like a canned good. Grill it for a couple of minutes, then flip the sandwich, compress it again and cook it for another few minutes.
Step 3: Slice and serve them
Slice the toasties in half and serve them hot, with a side of Taytos Chips if you have them!
Notes:
- You can quickly make diced, sautéed onion for this sandwich: finely dice some yellow onion, and heat up a little oil in a pan over medium heat. Sauté and stir the onions for about 5 minutes until they are soft and turning translucent.
- If you have a panini press, you can toast the sandwiches using it instead of the skillet. Ideally, you will toast the sandwiches with the flat plates.
The Toastie recipe is below. Here are more posts about our trip to Ireland, and the recipes it inspired:
>> How do you like my cheese toasties? Leave a comment for me below, leave a star rating! Had these in Ireland? Tell me more!
📖 Recipe
Ham, Onion & Cheese Toasties
Ingredients
- 4 slices white bread
- 2 tablespoons butter, salted
- 2 tablespoons mustard (or mayonnaise if you’d prefer)
- 3 ounces sliced Cheddar cheese (about 6 thin slices)
- 4 ounces sliced ham (about 8 thin slices)
- 3 tablespoons diced, sautéed onions (thin slices of pickled red onion would also be tasty here)
- ¼ cup canned baked beans (optional)
Instructions
Assemble the sandwiches:
- Lay out the slices of white bread and butter the top sides of them. Set two of them aside.
- Flip them over, and spread two of the slices with the mustard. Top each mustardy slice with one slice of the Cheddar cheese.
- Divide the ham between the two sandwiches and pile the ham on top of the mustard. Top the ham with the diced sautéed onion divided between the two sandwiches.
- If you are using beans, spoon the beans over the diced onion on both sandwiches.
- Finally, divide the remaining slices of Cheddar and place them over the fillings. Top each sandwich off with the two slices of bread you set aside, buttered sides up. (Both sides of the sandwich should have the buttered sides out.)
Toast the sandwiches
- Heat up a medium skillet over medium heat. If you are using a sandwich press turn it on and heat it up, ideally using flat plates instead of grooved. Place the assembled sandwiches in the hot pan or press.
- For a press: close the lid to compress and grill the sandwiches for 3-4 minutes until the bread is toasted on the outside and the cheese is melty. For a skillet: place something heavy on top of the sandwiches to compress them, like a small cast-iron skillet or like I did: a small cutting board weighted down by a jar of jam. Grill the sandwich for about 2 minutes until the bread is lightly browned. Flip it over, compress it, and grill for another 1-2 minutes. The cheese should be melted and the bread toasted on both sides.
- Slice the sandwiches in half and serve them immediately, with a side of Tayto Cheese & Onion chips if you can get them!
Notes
- You can quickly make diced, sautéed onion for this sandwich: finely dice some yellow onion, and heat up a little oil in a pan over medium heat. Sauté and stir the onions for about 5 minutes until they are soft and turning translucent.
- If you have a panini press, you can toast the sandwiches using it instead of the skillet. Ideally, you will toast the sandwiches with the flat plates.
Nutrition
I liked your recipe very much, however it didn’t produce the toasted special that I was looking for. In my recall the toasted specials did not have butter on the outside just crunch. Ofter served in a wax paper bag, for the life of me, I can’t reproduce it. But thanks for a great effort, I lived in Ireland for 8 years and am pretty sure of the texture of this toasted special, I kick myself in the butt for not nailing it then before my husband and I moved back to the states.
Hi Peggy,
Thank you for giving my take on Toasties a try! That’s so interesting about the Toasties you used to have. (And I didn’t know they’re also called Toasted Specials!) It sounds like the outside of the sandwich was dry-toasted – no butter, just bread directly on the skillet. I’ll have to try making one that way soon to taste the difference.
We loved our short visit to Ireland. Where did you and your husband used to live?
Yeah, we need to talk more about your trip sometime! Great post. I would love to see hurling! And I love your sister’s tattoo.
Didn’t know you were a whiskey fan. I love the stuff! Maybe we should plan a whiskey tasting sleepover party sometime. Or, once all the kids are out of the house, we should plan a trip to Kentucky/Tennessee for the four of us. Bourbon… mmm…
I agree, her tattoo is awesome!
I love the idea of a sleepover and field trip to the south. Yes, let’s get together soon and get our whiskey on!