Lots of Thanksgiving Pie Recipes

Pies and Thanksgiving go together like turkey and stuffing! Need some ideas for your holiday dessert? Here are delicious Thanksgiving pie recipes: a few traditional flavors and a few surprises!

I joined Meteorologost Amanda Thibault and anchors Brittney Hibbs and Megan Carpenter on the The Morning Brew program of Fox Local 44 news to talk about these pie ideas. (Pie-deas?) television station! for Thanksgiving Pies! Watch our segment below.

The Thanksgiving Pie Recipes are below!

And hey, need a great pie crust recipe? I have that for you, too. Make my Perfect All-Butter Pie Crust to hold whatever filling you choose. It is deliciously buttery and flaky. My post has the step-by-step instructions to help you make it with confidence!

Perfect All-Butter Pie Crust

This is the best pie crust for your sweet and savory pies. It is delicious thanks to the butter and a few special spices and flavorings. The crust is loaded with light and flaky layers.

Get this recipe

The Thanksgiving pie recipes are below. Check them out and please drop me a comment or question below if you have any.

Pumpkin Cranberry Hand Pies

Wrap up two delicious flavors of the holidays in these cute handheld pies. Flaky, all-butter pie crust holds spiced pumpkin filling and cranberry sauce.

Get this recipe

Vanilla Apple Pie

A delicious pie full of tart apple and rich vanilla flavor! It's made with a sweet, pâté sucrée style pie crust.

Get this recipe

Sweet Potato Pie

This lovely Sweet Potato Pie has a smooth filling of sweet potato and spices, all in a flaky pastry shell! It’s perfect for holiday time or for anytime you’re craving sweet potato sweetness!

Get this recipe

Chocolate Caramel Pie

This is one of my FAVORITE holiday pies – or any time of the year pies! A smooth chocolate filling along with caramel and homemade whipped cream. Yum!

Get this recipe

Cinnamon Blueberry Icebox Pie with A Snappy Crust

This a cool and creamy icebox pie with the flavor of cinnamon and summer blueberries. And the best thing about it is it’s a no-bake treat perfect for warm-weather days!

Get this recipe

Chilled Lemon & Lavender Pie

An unusual but beautifully-flavored icebox pie: full of creamy lemon flavor and scented with lavender. It’s a refreshing warm weather treat. 

Get this recipe

Toffee & Chocolate Chunk Pie

The flavors of a chocolate chip cookie but better: because this pie is loaded with rich, dark chocolate and pieces of sweet and crunchy toffee!

Get this recipe

Bailey’s Sweet Irish Cream Pie

This is a decadently sweet and creamy pie featuring the smooth flavor of Bailey’s Irish Cream! It’s also full of marshmallow, cream cheese and chocolate chips. 

NOTE: this recipe was revamped and updated 3/2019!

Get this recipe

Captain America’s All-American Apple Pie

What is Captain America’s favorite dessert? I bet it’s an all-American Apple Pie! Especially if it has the red, white and blue stripes of his mighty shield. 

Get this recipe

Have a very Happy Thanksgiving!